THE CHALLENGES AND EFFECTS OF DIGITAL MEDICAL DEVICES ON THE DOCTOR-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP, AS SEEN THROUGH THE LENS OF TREATING SLEEP APNOEA

Authors

  • Cristina LINDENMEYER
  • Bénédicte BÉVIÈRE-BOYER
  • Michael CHOCRON
  • Yanita ANDONOVA
  • Jean-Michel BESNIER
  • Grégory BONNET
  • Jean-Marc DELTORN
  • Marie-Pia D’ORTHO
  • Aloïse QUESNE
  • Gérard REYNIER
  • Geneviève VIDAL

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54695/jibes.341.0091

Keywords:

Digital, AI, Digital Medical Devices, Sleep apnoea, Medical relationship, Doctor, Patient, Health service provider.

Abstract

Tablets, smartphones, digital platforms, connected objects with or without Artificial Intelligence (AI) are invading our daily lives and transforming our relationships with others. Having already entered the field of wellness, in recent years we have seen the expectations and hopes raised by these new devices turn towards the field of health. In 2019, the European Parliament passed a resolution on a comprehensive European industrial policy on artificial intelligence and robotics 2, calling for caution in the use of algorithmic processes in the medical field and stressing that “the current system of approval of Digital Medical Devices may not be suitable for AI technologies”. Drawing on the framework of the treatment of sleep apnoea by continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP), our reflection highlights the fact that the increase in the amount of data, the acceleration of information, the disparity in the attractiveness and skills in IT and AI between the actors involved (doctors and patients), as well as the subjective effects of these changes lead to a redefinition of the doctor-patient relationship and a transformation of medical practice more generally.

Author Biography

Cristina LINDENMEYER

Cristina Lindenmeyer

 Suivre cet auteur

This research was carried out with the support of: The Person in Medicine Institute (ILPEM), Université Paris Cité and the Center for Internet and Society (CIS), CNRS (UPR 2000/ GDR 2091). It was based on an interdisciplinary survey which collected and analysed interviews with twenty physicians about their medical practice and the transformation caused by using connected medical devices. The analysis was carried out on a sample of practitioners of different ages, genders, training and modalities of practice, with respect to the treatment of a particular disease, the sleep apnoea syndrome, by a given method, continuous positive air pressure (CPAP). The question was then expanded to discuss generic connected medical devices and the use of Artificial Intelligence in medicine. The analysis of verbatim statements identified key themes related to the specificities of this treatment. It also brought out broader questions and reflections around the modalities of medical practice and the position of patients in the context of connected health. In May 2022, the working group “Health, Digital Technologies and AI”, part of the research group “The Centre for Internet, AI and Society” at CNRS (UPR 2000/ GDR 2091) directed by Cristina Lindenmeyer, produced a research report, The Challenges and Effects of Digital Medical Devices on the Doctor-Patient Relationship, as Seen through the Lens of Treating Sleep Apnoea, available online at: https://cis.cnrs.fr/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/vf-rapport-recherche-cis-ilpem.pdf This article was written based on this report and is published with the permission of the Person in Medicine Institute and the Center for Internet and Society, as well as the authors concerned.

Published

2023-04-01

How to Cite

LINDENMEYER, C. ., BÉVIÈRE-BOYER, B. ., CHOCRON, M. ., ANDONOVA, Y. ., BESNIER, J.-M., BONNET, G., DELTORN, J.-M. ., D’ORTHO, M.-P. ., QUESNE, A., REYNIER, G., & VIDAL, G. (2023). THE CHALLENGES AND EFFECTS OF DIGITAL MEDICAL DEVICES ON THE DOCTOR-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP, AS SEEN THROUGH THE LENS OF TREATING SLEEP APNOEA. Journal International De bioéthique Et d’éthique Des Sciences, 34(1), 91. https://doi.org/10.54695/jibes.341.0091

Issue

Section

Articles